Five Ways geeta

Krishna's Mercy HOME › FEATURE › FIVE WAYS TO TELL THAT THE BHAGAVAD-GITA FAVORS PERSONALISM OVER IMPERSONALISM Five Ways To Tell That The Bhagavad-gita Favors Personalism Over Impersonalism BY KRISHNASMERCY on JUNE 24, 2015 • ( 0 ) “For those whose minds are attached to the unmanifested, impersonal feature of the Supreme, advancement is very troublesome. To make progress in that discipline is always difficult for those who are embodied.” (Lord Krishna, Bhagavad-gita, 12.5) Download this episode (right click and save) kleśo ‘dhikataras teṣām avyaktāsakta-cetasām avyaktā hi gatir duḥkhaṁ dehavadbhir avāpyate Is there a God? Is He a person? If He indeed exists, does He have a form? Is not the Divine incorporeal, i.e. formless? How can any one form accurately identify Him? These questions have puzzled even intelligent minds for centuries. The Vedas give the most complete description, as to understand the Supreme one should also know about His infinite fragments. Life exists in the here and now. From where did it come? What are its properties? From knowing the soul, one can get a better idea of the origin of the soul. na tv evāhaṁ jātu nāsaṁ na tvaṁ neme janādhipāḥ na caiva na bhaviṣyāmaḥ sarve vayam ataḥ param “Never was there a time when I did not exist, nor you, nor all these kings; nor in the future shall any of us cease to be.” (Lord Krishna, Bhagavad-gita, 2.12) Vedanta is a Sanskrit word that means “the end of knowledge.” It is the conclusion of conclusions. The truths of Vedanta are succinct and yet profound at the same time. The Bhagavad-gita is an ancient Sanskrit work that perfectly summarizes Vedanta philosophy, going beyond it even. For the mind is but a product of the material nature, so philosophy can never be the true end to understanding. The fundamental truth of Vedanta is that the individual is spirit soul. In Sanskrit the phrase is “aham brahmasmi.” The literal translation is “I am Brahman.” Brahman is that which remains in existence eternally. Brahman is the animating force within everything that is living. That which is not Brahman is maya, or illusion. The easiest way to understand the distinction is to see the difference between a living body and a dead one. The living body has a spark of Brahman inside and the dead one is missing that spark. We have not mentioned a specific type of body. Brahman is not just inside the living human. It is also in the tiniest of germs, known as the indra-gopa in Sanskrit. It is inside the largest of bodies as well, such as the planets. The differences here relate only to maya, which is also known as the material nature. Vedanta philosophy focuses on Brahman realization. You should know that you are not your body, and you should have a practical realization of it as well. Beyond Vedanta philosophy is the creator. There is a creator to everything, and when you reach someone who was never created, you have found God. He is described in many other terms, such as the supreme controller, the supreme Brahman, and the original person. These descriptions, which have corresponding Sanskrit names as well, are different ways to help us understand God. Among those who follow Vedanta philosophy, the subtle dividing line is the issue of personalism versus impersonalism. Basically, do you think that God is a person or just an undifferentiated energy that is free of attributes? The impersonalist side says that there are divine beings who appear on earth every now and then, but they are simply elevated forms of the singular Brahman. The variety of life forms we see in this world is simply the fragmentation of Brahman. The personalist says that Brahman comes from the original Personality of Godhead. If the individual has a form, then how can it be absent in God? If God were formless, He would be inferior to others; it would negate His supreme standing. The various descents of the Divine to earth are in spiritual forms, meaning that for God there is no difference between matter and spirit. With the conflicting viewpoints who is there to reconcile? We can use the Bhagavad-gita, which both sides give respect to. Both sides quote from this most famous work, and both sides have written translations and commentaries. From the words in that book we can tell which is the superior path, impersonalism or personalism. 1. Krishna says that His form is spiritual The Bhagavad-gita is spoken by Shri Krishna, who is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Bhagavan. Bhagavan is the complete realization, while Paramatma and Brahman are less complete realizations of the same person. The impersonalist erroneously concludes that Krishna is merely an elevated soul. Some famous personalities even make the grave offense of calling Krishna a prophet. The Supreme Lord addresses this viewpoint directly in the Bhagavad-gita. He says that fools deride Him when He appears in the human form. They think that He has assumed the corporeal appearance they see in front of them. They do not know His actual nature, which is changeless and supreme. avyaktaṁ vyaktim āpannaṁ manyante mām abuddhayaḥ paraṁ bhāvam ajānanto mamāvyayam anuttamam “Unintelligent men, who know Me not, think that I have assumed this form and personality. Due to their small knowledge, they do not know My higher nature, which is changeless and supreme.” (Lord Krishna, Bg. 7.24) 2. Krishna says the impersonal path is more difficult The Bhagavad-gita is the most honest presentation. The Supreme Lord, who is the ultimate authority, Himself quotes other authority figures, as a matter of etiquette. Therefore the impersonal philosophy is not denied in Krishna’s words. It is readily acknowledged, but it is put in its proper place. Krishna says that the impersonal path is more difficult, especially for one who is embodied. Having taken birth in the material world, we are all embodied. We identify with maya from the start, so it’s difficult for us to understand what nirguna, or without material attributes, means. Nirguna means that Krishna has transcendental attributes. His hands and legs can do things human hands and legs can’t. His mouth can open wide enough to consume the entire universe. The path of personalism is favored since it gives a direct understanding of the full transcendental sweetness belonging exclusively to the Supreme Lord. The ultimate objective is bhakti, or love and devotion, and it is difficult to love someone you think is not even a person. 3. The word “mam” is used all the time. There is no doubt that in the Bhagavad-gita God is spoken of throughout. The speaker does not refer to God as a different person. He repeatedly uses the Sanskrit word “mam.” This translates to “me” or “unto me.” Krishna speaks these words to Arjuna, and so if God were incorporeal He would have told Arjuna to worship the God inside of himself. This does not happen, though the cheating speculator will try to twist the verses in this way. 4. The universal form was shown for only a brief period. To prove to the non-believers that Krishna is God, Arjuna asked his dear friend and cousin to show the universal form. This is a unique vision not available to the normal eyes. Arjuna was specifically granted a unique set of eyes to use to see this amazing form. The virata-rupa, which is the form of everything, includes all the planets and the many creatures populating it. Yet this form was shown for only a brief time. If the impersonal path were superior, the universal form would have been the platform from which Krishna spoke the majority of His words. Instead, it was the two-handed form that delivered the Bhagavad-gita, and it was the form that Arjuna preferred as well. 5. Krishna spoke to Arjuna; not a voice from the sky. There are many books based on the teachings of the Bhagavad-gita that won’t dare to mention Krishna’s name. Some translations even have Krishna cropped out of the cover. They will feature the subtitle, “God speaks to Arjuna.” But from the work itself, which is included in the much larger historical and philosophical anthology known as the Mahabharata, we know that it was indeed a person who spoke to Arjuna. “Then a voice, sounding like a human being, was heard from the sky which said, ‘O king, this child is rightfully your daughter.’” (Sita Devi speaking to Anasuya, Valmiki Ramayana, Ayodhya Kand, 118.31) If God were indeed impersonal, He would have spoken to Arjuna from afar. He would have appeared on the scene as a voice from the sky. Indeed, in Vedic literature it is not uncommon to find references to such voices. One time a king named Janaka found a baby girl in the ground and wasn’t sure what to do next. A voice from the sky then appeared and told him that the girl was indeed his daughter in all righteousness. The Conclusion The acharyas give the authorized commentaries and translations of the Bhagavad-gita. The bona fide acharyas follow the example of Arjuna, who is devoted to Krishna in thought, word and deed. Arjuna heard the Bhagavad-gita directly and took to heart the ultimate conclusion, that of surrender to Krishna the person. Thus the person who first heard the words gives the most powerful testimony in favor of the path of personalism. In Closing: Lesson from Arjuna detect, Who heard Krishna’s words direct. Universal form not there entire time, Nor voice from sky with light to shine. Krishna the person before him standing, And to him giving proper understanding. That personalism path the favorite one, And impersonalism with more difficulty done. Share this: PrintEmailFacebook2TumblrTwitterGoogleReddit ‹ Five Ways That Arjuna Can Relate To YouFive Reasons Prahlada Is the Best Son You Could Ask For › Categories: feature, the fiveTags: articles, feature, hare krishna, meditation, news Leave a Reply Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked * Name * Email * Website Comment You may use these HTML tags and attributes:

    



 Notify me of new comments via email.

 Notify me of new posts via email.

Membership

Please enter your email address to join our daily e-newsletter.





Top Rated

Growing Up A King’s Daughter
The One With The Indirect Praise
Where Do You Want To Live
The Benefits of Controlling the Mind
Without Envy
Variety In One
The One With All The Best Things
Lack of Inquisitiveness
Using All Your Intellect
The One With The Team Captain
Random Posts

Click here for random post
Recent Posts

Five Reasons Prahlada Is the Best Son You Could Ask For
Five Ways To Tell That The Bhagavad-gita Favors Personalism Over Impersonalism
Five Ways That Arjuna Can Relate To You
Sankirtana For The Ages
Talking About Miracle Men
Understanding Pure Devotion
Writing Down To Remember
Talking About What God Must Be
Remembering From Where Your Power Comes
Caste Brahmanas
Brahmanas and Vaishnavas
The Value of Seeing
My Choice
Insulting Hari
Fire and Brimstone
Prabhupada Books




Most Viewed

Five Ways To Tell That The Bhagavad-gita Favors Personalism Over Impersonalism
Five Reasons Prahlada Is the Best Son You Could Ask For
Five Ways That Arjuna Can Relate To You
Why Do People Die
Talking About Miracle Men
Lord Krishna
Sankirtana For The Ages
Vishnu Worship
Understanding Pure Devotion
Known For Following Principles
Links

 Our Amazon Books
 Our Podcast
Facebook


RECENT COMMENTS

	Ashish Kumar on Understanding Pure Devotion
	Jigger on Writing Down To Remember
	joeythebuddhist on Brahmanas and Vaishnavas
	shambhu on Clearing Our Vision
	sunit kumar ghosh on Excusing Offenses Made Directl…
TRANSLATE

Translate this blog into different languages... 

Albanian Arabic Bulgarian Catalan Chinese Simplified Chinese Traditional Croatian Czech Danish Dutch Estonian Filipino Finnish French Galician German Greek Hebrew Hindi Hungarian Indonesian Italian Japanese Korean Lativian Lithuanian Maltese Norwegian Polish Portuguese Romanian Russian Serbian Slovak Slovenian Spanish Swedish Thai Turkish Ukrainian Vietnamese
RECENT POSTS: BHAKTI POEMS

Against Time
Cold In The Summer
Let The Smile Deliver You
Easy To Lament
Even After Thousands of Years
POPULAR LINKS

krishnasmercy.podbean.com…
krishnastore.com/bhagavad…
krishnasmercy.podbean.com…
krishnasmercy.org/dotnetn…
krishnasmercy.files.wordp…
lh6.ggpht.com/_RWM6XqnZgi…
lh5.ggpht.com/_RWM6XqnZgi…
krishnasmercy.files.wordp…
krishnastore.com/science-…
bhaktipoems.com/2015/06/1…
CATEGORIES

bhagavad-gita (28)
bhagavan (39)
chaitanya (10)
chanting (38)
charity (11)
children (14)
conversations (60)
cows (2)
damodara (33)
deity worship (27)
devotional service (77)
disease (10)
diwali (6)
dohavali 1-40 (56)
dohavali 41-80 (59)
dussehra (6)
economy (3)
education (8)
equality (12)
false ego (2)
fame (2)
fear (5)
feature (40)
four regulative principles (16)
gaura purnima (7)
global warming (4)
glories of lakshmana (34)
glories of sita devi (72)
gopis (10)
govardhana (6)
government (26)
hanuman (2)
hanuman crossing the ocean (10)
hanuman describing rama (28)
hanuman entering ashoka (17)
hanuman entering lanka (30)
hanuman meets sita (26)
hanuman overcoming depression (35)
hanuman sowing dissension (11)
hanuman spotting sita (23)
hanuman spotting sita 2 (50)
hearing (23)
holi (6)
holiday (56)
honesty (3)
intoxication (4)
janaki mangala (261)
janmashtami (6)
karma (34)
kindness (3)
knowledge (28)
krishna pastimes (52)
krishna showing universal form (21)
kunjavihari (22)
lakshmana counselling rama (35)
liberation (4)
love (9)
maricha describing rama (11)
marriage (6)
mayavada (22)
meat eating (4)
meeting hanuman (21)
meeting shabari (8)
memory (9)
mercy (4)
mode of passion (10)
narasimha (8)
parents (2)
pilgrimage (6)
prasadam (14)
prayer (3)
preaching (28)
protecting the saints (15)
questions (28)
radha (5)
radhashtami (6)
rama navami (7)
ramayana (14)
ravana threatening sita (53)
ravana threatening sita 2 (24)
reading (19)
reflections (1)
regulative principles (3)
reincarnation (37)
religion (59)
renunciation (20)
sacrifice (9)
science (38)
searching for sita (26)
shikshashtakam (14)
shiva (2)
sita and hanuman (29)
sita describing her marriage (12)
sita identifying herself (20)
sita warning ravana (18)
spiritual master (36)
spotting hanuman (13)
stories (57)
sugriva praising hanuman (17)
tapasya (11)
the five (3)
the fruit vendor (12)
thinking (10)
time (1)
varnashrama dharma (9)
violence (4)
vishnu (6)
vyasa puja (6)
yoga (29)
POSTS BY DATE

June 2015
M	T	W	T	F	S	S
« May	 	 
1	2	3	4	5	6	7
8	9	10	11	12	13	14
15	16	17	18	19	20	21
22	23	24	25	26	27	28
29	30	 
NAVIGATION

Contact
Membership
Related
Worship
Lord Krishna
Lord Ramachandra
Lord Chaitanya
His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada
Goswami Tulsidas
Krishna Dwaipayana Vyasa
Maharishi Valmiki
Teachings
Beginning Steps
Prasadam
Chanting
The Four Regulative Principles
Deity Worship
Essentials
Book Recommendations
Science of Self Realization
Bhagavad-gita As It Is
Krishna Book
Shrimad Bhagavatam
Chaitanya Charitamrita
Songs
Shri Krishna Chaitanya – Hare Krishna
Namaste Narasimhaya
Jaya Sita Rama
ARCHIVE

June 2015 (25)
May 2015 (31)
April 2015 (30)
March 2015 (31)
February 2015 (28)
January 2015 (31)
December 2014 (32)
November 2014 (30)
October 2014 (31)
September 2014 (30)
August 2014 (31)
July 2014 (31)
June 2014 (30)
May 2014 (31)
April 2014 (30)
March 2014 (31)
February 2014 (28)
January 2014 (31)
December 2013 (31)
November 2013 (30)
October 2013 (31)
September 2013 (30)
August 2013 (31)
July 2013 (31)
June 2013 (30)
May 2013 (31)
April 2013 (30)
March 2013 (31)
February 2013 (28)
January 2013 (31)
December 2012 (31)
November 2012 (30)
October 2012 (31)
September 2012 (31)
August 2012 (31)
July 2012 (31)
June 2012 (30)
May 2012 (31)
April 2012 (30)
March 2012 (32)
February 2012 (29)
January 2012 (31)
December 2011 (31)
November 2011 (30)
October 2011 (31)
September 2011 (30)
August 2011 (31)
July 2011 (31)
June 2011 (30)
May 2011 (31)
April 2011 (30)
March 2011 (31)
February 2011 (28)
January 2011 (31)
December 2010 (31)
November 2010 (30)
October 2010 (31)
September 2010 (31)
August 2010 (30)
July 2010 (31)
June 2010 (30)
May 2010 (32)
April 2010 (30)
March 2010 (31)
February 2010 (28)
January 2010 (31)
December 2009 (31)
November 2009 (30)
October 2009 (31)
September 2009 (30)
August 2009 (31)
July 2009 (31)
June 2009 (13)
April 2009 (3)
March 2009 (4)
February 2009 (4)
BLOG AT WORDPRESS.COM. | THE OPTI THEME.